Error message

  • Notice: Undefined index: und in __lambda_func() (line 11 of /srv/www/genetics.thetech.org/htdocs/sites/all/modules/views_php/plugins/views/views_php_handler_field.inc(202) : runtime-created function).
  • Notice: Undefined index: und in __lambda_func() (line 20 of /srv/www/genetics.thetech.org/htdocs/sites/all/modules/views_php/plugins/views/views_php_handler_field.inc(202) : runtime-created function).
  • Notice: Undefined index: und in __lambda_func() (line 20 of /srv/www/genetics.thetech.org/htdocs/sites/all/modules/views_php/plugins/views/views_php_handler_field.inc(202) : runtime-created function).
  • Notice: Undefined index: und in __lambda_func() (line 29 of /srv/www/genetics.thetech.org/htdocs/sites/all/modules/views_php/plugins/views/views_php_handler_field.inc(202) : runtime-created function).
Other Traits

Can moderate amounts of exercise as a child make you taller as an adult?

-A curious adult from Florida

November 9, 2011

How tall we are comes from both our genes and our environment. Genes give a sort of maximum possible height. How we live our lives determines whether or not we can reach that potential.

Environment is a catch all word for everything we do, where we live, and what we experience. It includes what we eat, how much we exercise, and most everything else.

Until recently, most of the focus has been on how what we eat affects our height. For example, people who don't get enough protein when they are growing up end up shorter than they could be. But we don't yet have a definite answer on whether exercise can increase someone's height.

We do know that animals that get a lot of exercise end up with longer bones. And that exercise causes animals to make extra growth hormone and testosterone (both of which can lead to being taller). We also know that early exercise makes people's bones stronger.

What we don't know yet is whether people that exercised a lot as children end up taller than they might have been if they had slacked off. The animal studies suggest that exercise could make people 1 to 2 inches taller but we don't yet know for sure. You can bet, though, that scientists are looking into this and we may have a better idea soon.

So while exercise has many benefits, no one has proven that it can make you taller. But believe it or not, scientists have shown that it can sometimes make you shorter! Some athletes, like gymnasts, actually end up shorter because they exercise so much.

A Balance of Genes and Environment

Let's look at an example of how this works. For the rest of the answer I want to focus on a made up pair of sisters, Jane and Jill. Because they are identical twins, they have the exact same set of genes.

This means that if their environments were exactly the same, then they'd end up the same height. A big reason for this is that studies that have looked at identical twins like them have shown that height is about 90% genetic.

Of course, the 10% difference shows that genes aren't everything! If they were, identical twins would be exactly alike. And if you know any identical twins, you know they can be very different.

The differences come from the things that each identical twin does. It also comes from what is available to them from the environment.

Think about height like building a skyscraper. The genes are like the plans. If you have everything you need in terms of steel, workers, etc., then you can end up with the Empire State Building.

The environment is really like the supplies. If you don't have enough steel, you're not going to go 100 stories high. You may end up with 80 stories instead (which is still pretty impressive!).

This is what happens if you don't get enough to eat while you're growing up. The plans (your genes) say to make you 6 feet tall. But you don't get enough calcium or protein and so you can only build 5' 10" worth of bones. And this is what happens to Jane.

Jane the Gymnast

Let's get back to our twins. Jane is an elite gymnast and trains for hours every day. In fact, Jane exercises so much that she burns more energy than she takes in.

This means that she's actually short on building supplies, even though she eats lots of healthy food. Her body can't build long enough bones and so she's shorter than Jill.

In fact, she could end up quite a bit shorter. Scientists have found that children who eat a low-protein diet can be almost 5 inches shorter than those who eat a healthy diet.

Jill the Couch Potato

Jane's twin sister Jill, on the other hand, is quite the couch potato. But it turns out she's actually taller than Jane!

She burned off the same amount as she ate so she had plenty of supplies to get to her projected height. But the question is, could she have ended up even taller had she exercised more? Did she not get to her full potential height?

As I pointed out in the introduction, we just don't know yet. We do know that even though Jane is shorter than Jill, her bones are actually stronger. There's lots of research in animals and people that shows that exercise makes your bones thicker and stronger.

We also know that if Jill were a mouse she would end up longer (taller) if she exercised more. Evidence from animal studies suggests that exercise might make bones longer.

This research also shows that exercise makes cells release two hormones that increase bone length. These hormones are called growth hormone and testosterone.

What we don't know is whether Jill's extra testosterone and/or growth hormone would have much of an effect on her height. Scientists still need to work that out.

So to maximize your height, eat a healthy diet. And even if it doesn't make you taller, moderate amounts of exercise will give you strong bones too!

Susan Roehl White


We know food can affect height.  The jury is still out on whether exercise can.


Genes are like the plans for a tall building. Food and exercise are like the building materials.

 

 


People who exercise too much may not reach their genetic potential for height.


We don't know if more exercise will make one twin taller than the other.